
S&P Keeps Tether's USDT at Weakest Stability Score as Higher-Risk Reserves Reach 28%
S&P Global Ratings reaffirmed its lowest stability score, 5 (weak), for Tether's USDT in a November 18 assessment. The agency said higher-risk assets equal to 28% of circulating USDT could leave the stablecoin undercollateralized in a downturn, a claim Tether disputes.
Written by CoinArticle’s AI Newsroom · from 2 cited sources. How we work
What S&P Reaffirmed
S&P Global Ratings kept Tether's USDT at 5 (weak), the lowest level on its five-point stablecoin stability scale, in an assessment dated November 18. The score is unchanged from November 2025, when S&P lowered USDT from 4 (constrained). The agency said the assessment measures the ability to maintain the dollar peg and is not a formal credit rating.
S&P said assets it classes as higher risk equaled 28% of circulating USDT as of September 30, up from 24% a year earlier. It warned that a significant fall in the value of those assets "could lead to USDT being undercollateralized." Its higher-risk category includes corporate bonds, secured loans and other investments exposed to market prices, interest rates and borrower creditworthiness.
How Reserves Have Shifted
According to crypto.news, gold holdings rose from $12.9 billion in September 2025 to about $19 billion a year later, while Bitcoin holdings fell from $9.9 billion to $8.4 billion. Tether also disclosed $4.2 billion in public equity investments over the same period. Crypto Briefing reported the equity allocation and the increase in gold holdings as well, and both outlets describe the same reserve shift.
S&P noted that the value of higher-risk assets substantially exceeded Tether's reported reserve surplus. Crypto.news reported that the surplus, the excess of reserves over liabilities, nearly doubled from $4.11 billion at the end of June to $7.95 billion at the end of September.
Disputed Reserve Figures and Transparency
The sources give consistent but differently framed collateral figures. Crypto.news cites an attested $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, a 104.3% collateralization ratio as of September 30, attested by BDO Italia. Crypto.news also reports direct and indirect exposure to U.S. Treasury bills of $132.4 billion. Neither source says S&P disputes those headline totals; its objection concerns the risk and disclosure of the non-Treasury portion.
Transparency remains the central point of contention. Tether announced in August that KPMG U.S. had issued an unqualified opinion on its 2025 financial statements, and said KPMG physically counted every gold bar held. S&P said the full statements, notes and auditor's report were still not public, limiting its review. Tether's quarterly reserve reports do not name custodians, banking partners or counterparties, and S&P found disclosure on secured loans and corporate bonds insufficient.
Tether's Response and Regulatory Questions
Tether CEO Paolo Ardoino has rejected the rating. He wrote on X that the company "wear[s] your loathing with pride," called the traditional rating system a "propaganda machine," and said Tether was overcapitalized, held "no toxic reserves" and remained highly profitable. Tether told Cointelegraph that the problem was S&P's framework rather than its reserves.
S&P also questioned the legal protections for USDT reserves after Tether moved its domicile from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador in 2025. Tether now operates under El Salvador's National Commission of Digital Assets, which requires issuers to hold at least one dollar of reserve assets for each stablecoin dollar. Neither source reports a specific S&P finding on how that regime affects segregation or recourse in an insolvency.
Why It Matters
For Traders
A reaffirmed weak score and a 28% higher-risk share give USDT peg-sensitive positions a concrete downside scenario to monitor, though the reported 104.3% collateralization ratio currently covers liabilities.
For Investors
The dispute centers on reserve composition and disclosure, so the durability of USDT's dollar backing will depend on whether full audited statements and custodian details are published.
For Builders
Protocols that accept USDT as collateral or settlement should reassess their exposure limits and counterparty assumptions in light of the rising share of non-cash-equivalent reserves.
This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.






