Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank Appeal, Leaving Fed Master Account Discretion Intact
RegulationAdoption
Neutral

Supreme Court Declines Custodia Bank Appeal, Leaving Fed Master Account Discretion Intact

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear Custodia Bank's appeal over the Federal Reserve's refusal to grant it a master account, leaving a Tenth Circuit ruling in place. The decision confirms Reserve Banks have discretion to deny even legally eligible nonmember banks access to Fed payment rails.

Nov 16, 2026, 03:29 PM3 min read

Written by CoinArticle’s AI Newsroom · from 2 cited sources. How we work

What the Court Did

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to review Custodia Bank, Inc. v. Federal Reserve Board of Governors, No. 26-62, a certiorari denial listed on the Court's Monday order list. The Wyoming special purpose depository institution had asked the justices to decide whether the Monetary Control Act of 1980 gives regional Federal Reserve Bank presidents discretion to deny master accounts to legally eligible nonmember banks. The Court distributed the petition for its November 13 conference before turning it down. No explanation accompanied the order.

The denial leaves in place the Tenth Circuit's October 31, 2025 decision, which ruled 2-1 that the Reserve Bank may refuse an account to an eligible applicant. Both reporting sources agree on the procedural outcome. Crypto Briefing describes the practical result as closing the door, since a denial of certiorari carries no reasoning that would bind future courts.

How the Dispute Reached the Top Court

Custodia applied for a master account at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City in October 2020, after receiving its Wyoming charter. In January 2021 the Kansas City Fed told the bank it was legally eligible and that there were "no showstoppers," according to Bitcoin Magazine. The Reserve Bank formally denied the application on January 27, 2023. It cited an "unprecedented" business model "narrowly focused on crypto-asset activities" and concluded the risks were "highly likely" to be inconsistent with safe and sound banking practices. The Board of Governors separately denied Custodia's Federal Reserve membership application the same day.

Custodia sued in June 2022 over the delay. A Wyoming district court ruled for the Fed in March 2024, holding that the Federal Reserve Act gives Reserve Banks discretion over master accounts. The Tenth Circuit affirmed. Judge David Ebel, joined by Judge Veronica Rossman, held that the Act's language permitting Reserve Banks to receive deposits is discretionary, and that the Monetary Control Act's provision that Fed services "shall be available" to nonmember banks sets pricing rules rather than creating a right to an account.

Where the Sources Disagree on the Reasoning

The two outlets frame the statutory fight differently. Crypto Briefing presents the core question as whether eligibility guarantees access or merely places a bank in line. Bitcoin Magazine reports the same dispute through the specific statutory language, quoting Judge Timothy Tymkovich's dissent that "shall means shall" and that the 1980 law "mandates access to the Fed's payment services for all nonmember depository institutions." Tymkovich argued that denial of an account is "akin to a death sentence" for a bank. The majority read the same words as a pricing instruction. Neither outlet suggests the Supreme Court endorsed either reading. Both note that the denial of review carries no reasoning.

Fed Practice and Case-by-Case Decisions

The Kansas City Fed's approach appears inconsistent on its face. In March 2025 the same Reserve Bank granted Kraken Financial a limited-purpose master account, according to Crypto Briefing. Kraken is also crypto-focused. Supporters of the Fed's position say that individualized review of each applicant's risk profile is what discretion requires. Critics say similar businesses receive very different answers without a clear explanation. The Board's 2022 guidelines placed firms neither federally insured nor supervised by a federal banking agency in a "Tier 3" category that "generally receive[s] the strictest level of review," a category Custodia fell into.

What Comes Next

For Custodia, the litigation path is exhausted. For other digital asset banks, the implications are narrower but significant. Crypto Briefing argues that future applicants seeking access through courts now face a steeper climb, and that applicants will likely need to persuade the Fed directly. Bitcoin Magazine's summary is that state charters, even those that make a bank legally eligible, do not guarantee entry to the Fed's payment system. Crypto Briefing identifies Congress as the next possible venue. If lawmakers want eligibility to guarantee access, the statute would need to say so explicitly. Neither source reports a pending legislative proposal on the question.

Why It Matters

For Traders

Crypto-linked equities and tokens with exposure to banking partnerships face no immediate change, though the ruling removes a litigation route some digital asset firms had been counting on.

For Investors

The ruling confirms that Fed master account access for novel charters depends on regulator discretion, which makes case-by-case approvals such as Kraken's a key signal to track.

For Builders

Teams building stablecoin or settlement products on bank rails should plan around correspondent banking relationships rather than assuming direct Fed payment access is attainable.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Related Articles

Latest News