Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case
RegulationSecurity
Neutral

Judge Acquits MIT Brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV Case

A Manhattan federal judge acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on wire fraud, conspiracy and money laundering charges tied to a 2023 Ethereum MEV exploit that cost trading bots about $25 million. The ruling found prosecutors did not prove the material misrepresentation required for fraud, closing the case without a retrial.

Nov 17, 2026, 03:09 PM3 min read

Written by CoinArticle’s AI Newsroom · from 2 cited sources. How we work

The Ruling

U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted the Peraire-Bueno brothers' motion for a judgment of acquittal on Monday, dismissing charges of wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering, according to her ruling. The decision ends the criminal case without a second trial.

Clarke found that none of the government's theories showed the material misrepresentation that wire fraud requires. Because the money laundering count depended on proceeds of the alleged fraud, it fell with the fraud counts. Clarke separated the legal question from the ethical one, writing that the issue "is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral."

The Alleged Exploit

The case stems from an April 2023 attack on sandwich bots, automated traders that profit from maximal extractable value (MEV) by placing trades on either side of other users' transactions. Prosecutors alleged the brothers placed bait transactions to lure specific bots, then exploited a bug in a relay's code to see the bots' bundled trades before block inclusion. They then swapped the bait for trades that sold the tokens, leaving the bots with roughly $25 million in losses in about 12 seconds. The pair was arrested in May 2024.

Reporting on the mechanics differs in emphasis. Decrypt describes the bait-and-switch as using a relay bug to view bundles before committing to a block. NewsBTC, citing Reuters and The Block, frames it more broadly as manipulation of validator infrastructure that diverted value bots expected to capture. Both accounts agree on the roughly $25 million figure and the 12-second window.

Limits of the Decision

Clarke wrote that Ethereum is a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," and that the brothers' scheme "may have frustrated the spirit" of MEV-Boost without amounting to fraud. In a footnote she said the prosecution "raises serious due process concerns," but she did not rule on that question.

The acquittal is narrow. It addresses whether this conduct, as charged and proved, met the legal test for fraud. It does not endorse MEV extraction generally. NewsBTC cautions that describing the ruling as legalizing MEV attacks would overstate what the court decided, and that other facts, jurisdictions or statutory claims could produce different outcomes.

Trial History and Industry Response

The case went through substantial litigation before reaching this result. At trial last year, an insider testified that the brothers had planned the attack, and the defense had sought to exclude evidence of their Google searches. Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025 after the jury deadlocked. Clarke herself called the prosecution a "first of its kind" case, a label the government used in its indictment.

For traders and developers, the ruling leaves the technical problem unresolved. Transaction ordering and block building still determine execution prices and who captures value, and relays, builders and validators face trade-offs between permissionlessness, censorship resistance and fairness if they change their software.

Why It Matters

For Traders

Users trading on Ethereum should note that the acquittal does not reduce MEV-related execution risk, so slippage controls and routing choices remain the practical safeguards.

For Investors

The ruling narrows how fraud statutes apply to on-chain ordering, which lowers prosecution risk for MEV operators but leaves regulatory treatment of the practice unsettled.

For Builders

Relay and builder code faces scrutiny after a bug enabled early bundle visibility, so auditing bundle-handling logic is now a clearer operational priority.

This article is for information only and is not financial advice. Read the full disclaimer.

Live prices:Ethereum

Related Articles

Latest News